Telegram claims to have 900 million users worldwide. With a huge user base, and the introduction of the TON blockchain, the "International WeChat Mini Program" developed by Telegram has also begun to flourish. In the cryptocurrency community, many people are involved in the “Tap to Earn” game and meme currency community in Telegram. What’s interesting is that the Telegram communities for these projects often number in the millions, which is far larger than their communities on

We will take you through the Telegram tool to explore the reality!

Telemetrio, the anti-counterfeit fan tool: Seeing through the "processing" subscription behavior of TG channels

Search for "@telemetr_io_bot" on Telegram and you can find a robot that queries Telegram channel statistics. It claims to be Telemetr, a data analysis company from Ukraine. You can use the command "/channelstat" to further search for the Telegram channel you want to check, or go directly to the official website.

Case of suspicious subscription growth: Is this buying fake fans?

Take this channel labeled China (the most interactive user area) (76,786 subscribers as of press time).

From the subscription growth curve analyzed by Telemetr, we can see that the number of daily subscribers of the channel has been mostly flat in the past 30 days, but it only surged by 48,335 subscribers on July 30, forming a violent fluctuation and tending to an unnatural situation.

Other data shows that the channel has approximately 1,401 views in the past 24 hours, approximately 1,589 views in 48 hours, and an “Engagement Rate” of 2.61%.

Looking further at the detailed data, we can see that the channel's subscriber growth in the past has not exceeded double digits every day. However, there was a single-day subscriber growth of 48,335 on July 30, and another 760 on July 31, adding up to a nearly round number of 49,095, which is quite unnatural. It is expected that the subsequent unnatural growth will reach 50,000, and it will be more likely to lead to fan buying behavior.

Check out TON’s popular memes and blockchain game results?

NOTCOIN Community

The Notcoin channel, which has 12 million subscribers (1.7 million tracked by The "Engagement Rate" performed well at 26.89%, and the post had 2.19 million views in the past 24 hours. The user area with the most interactions was judged to be Russia.

Judging from the changes in the number of subscribers, there has been a surge in the past month, starting from less than 9 million subscribers at the end of July to 12 million subscribers in a few days, after a relatively stable growth in July.

It is more intuitive to look at the daily growth data. It maintained a daily growth of tens of thousands of people in mid-July, but between 7/26 and 7/31, there were hundreds of thousands to millions of subscribers added every day. However, compared with the NOT currency price, there is no significant increase in the time frame range, and it shows a decline, or the major news is announced and there is no motivation for the community to join in large numbers.

Hamster Kombat

Hamster Kombat's Announcement channel has 53 million subscribers (X tracking 12.4 million), down 36,478 in the past 24 hours, 294,717 in the past seven days, and a massive gain of 4.43 million subscribers in the past 30 days. The number of views of the post in the past 24 hours was 8.97 million, and the "Engagement Rate" performance was very high, at 64.94%. Judging from its high interaction performance, it is relatively natural. There is no specific area where users interact the most.

The increase in the number of subscribers in the past month has been relatively flat. However, since the number of subscribers of this project has increased from one million to ten million in April, subsequent fluctuations, although around the million level, are difficult to express on the chart.

Looking at the daily growth data, you will find that the current growth of this project has increased and decreased, except for some days when there was an increase of hundreds of thousands. Generally, the increase or decrease remains in the tens of thousands, indicating that the community may no longer be growing at a high speed.

Catizen

Recent hit Catizen has 5.25 million subscribers (X tracks 2 million), adding 3,515 in the past 24 hours, 145,142 in the past seven days, and 620,000 in the past 30. The number of views of the post in the past 24 hours was 390,000, and the "Engagement Rate" was 14.96%, which is the lowest of the two cases mentioned above. The user area with the most interactions was judged to be Russia.

Judging from the growth curve in the past 30 days, it tends to be a step-like growth:

Looking at the daily growth data, the number of people increases and decreases. Most of them remain in the thousands to tens of thousands, with only a few days showing a sudden increase of hundreds of thousands:

Compare with the founder of Telegram

Number of Telegram subscribers

Judging from the table above, if Telegram has an "out-of-group community" that Twitter does not have, and judging from the Telegram founder community that has no motivation to create fake accounts to grab airdrops, it can be assumed that this "out-of-group" ratio can be amplified by 4.54 times , among which Hamster Kombat has the same ratio, and Catizen is far lower than the benchmark value. However, the Tap to Earn meme coin of NOTCOIN Community is significantly inflated. Judging from the subscription growth curve above, NOTCOIN’s curve also deviates from nature.

Generally speaking, due to the craze of Telegram, there are many "studios" that provide services of buying likes, buying tracking or click-through rates. Facing the community growth data reported daily by media communities, it is recommended to treat it neutrally. Through our The tools introduced can also help you see which communities are growing more naturally. In other words, buy into these interactions more professionally.

[Disclaimer] There are risks in the market, so investment needs to be cautious. This article does not constitute investment advice, and users should consider whether any opinions, views or conclusions contained in this article are appropriate for their particular circumstances. Invest accordingly and do so at your own risk.

• This article is reprinted with permission from: "Chain News"