Brief Summary
Isolated Margin and cross margin are two different types of margin offered on many cryptocurrency trading platforms.
In isolated margin, investors decide how much funds to allocate as collateral for a particular position, and the rest of their account balance is not affected by this action.
Cross margin uses the entire available funds in your account as collateral for all transactions. If one position moves against you while another makes a profit, that profit can be used to cover the loss. So you can keep the position open for a longer period of time.
The choice between isolated margin and cross margin depends on one's trading strategy, risk tolerance, and how actively one wants to manage one's positions.
What is Margin Trading?
Before moving on to isolated margin and cross margin, let's talk briefly about margin trading. In margin trading, investors borrow money from an exchange or broker to buy or sell more assets than they can afford on their own. They use the assets in their accounts as collateral to borrow money and trade higher amounts in the hope of making a higher profit.
Let's say you have 5,000 USD and you think the price of Bitcoin will rise. You can buy $5,000 of Bitcoin directly or use leverage on your position to trade with borrowed funds. Let's say the price of Bitcoin increases by 20%. If you invested only your $5,000 without using leverage, the current value of your investment would be $6,000 ($5,000 you originally invested + $1,000 profit). This means you earn 20% on your initial investment.
But if you use 5x leverage with your $5,000 fund, you borrow four times your holding and invest $25,000 ($5,000 and $20,000 credit from your initial capital). When the price of Bitcoin rises by 20%, your $25,000 investment becomes worth $30,000 ($25,000 initial investment + $5,000 profit). After repaying your $20,000 loan, you will be left with $10,000. This means you get a 100% return on your initial $5,000 investment.
However, it should not be forgotten that margin trading is extremely risky. Let's examine the opposite scenario, where the price of Bitcoin falls by 20%. Without leverage, your $5,000 investment would lose 20%, with the value falling to $4,000 (initial $5,000 - $1,000 loss). But when you use 5x leverage, the value of your investment decreases from $25,000 to $20,000 (initial $25,000 - $5,000 loss). Once you pay off your $20,000 loan, you are left with nothing, which means you lose 100% of your initial investment.
This simple example does not include trading commissions or interest that you would have to pay on borrowed funds in real trading scenarios, which could reduce your profits. It is important to remember that the market can move quickly, causing losses that may even exceed your initial investment.
What is Isolated Margin?
Isolated margin and cross margin are two different types of margin offered on many cryptocurrency trading platforms. Each mode has its own advantages and risks. Let's examine what these are and how they work.
In isolated margin mode, the margin amount is limited to a specific position. This means that you decide how much of your funds you want to allocate as collateral for a particular position, and the rest of your funds will not be affected by that transaction.
Let's say you have an account with a total balance of 10 BTC. You decide to open a leveraged long position in ether (ETH), thinking that the price of ETH will rise. You allocated 2 BTC as isolated margin for this transaction with 5x leverage. This means you are actually trading 10 BTC worth of ether (your 2 BTC + 8 BTC leveraged position).
If the price of Ether rises and you decide to close the position, any profit you make will be added to the 2 BTC margin you used for this transaction. But if the price of ether drops sharply, you will lose your isolated margin of at most 2 BTC. Even if your position is liquidated, the other 8 BTC in your account will not be affected. Hence the name "isolated" margin.
What is Cross Margin?
Cross margin uses all available funds in your account as collateral for your transactions. If one position moves against you while another position makes a profit, that profit can be used to cover the loss. So you can keep the position open for a longer period of time.
Let's examine how this works through an example. Let's say you have a total balance of 10 BTC. You decide to open a leveraged long position in ether (ETH) using cross margin and another leveraged short position in a cryptocurrency we call Z. For Ether, you trade 4 BTC using 2x leverage, and for Z, you trade 6 BTC using 2x leverage. Your entire account balance of 10 BTC is used as collateral for both positions.
Let's say the price of Ether falls, causing a loss, but at the same time, the price of Z also falls, bringing a profit on your short position. The profit from transaction Z can be used to cover the loss on ether, so both positions can be kept open.
But if the price of ether falls and the price of Z rises, both of your positions could be at a loss. If this loss exceeds your total account balance, both positions may be liquidated and you may lose your entire balance of 10 BTC in your account. This is quite different from isolated margin, where you only risk losing the 2 BTC you set aside for the transaction.
Please note that these are extremely simplified examples and do not include trading commissions and other expenses. Moreover, real trading scenarios are often much more complex.
Major Differences Between Isolated Margin and Cross Margin
From the above examples, we can clearly see the similarities and differences between isolated margin and cross margin trading. We can summarize the main differences as follows:
Collateral and liquidation mechanisms
In isolated margin, only a certain portion of your funds are set aside and put at risk for a specific transaction. This means that if you are trading 2 BTC in isolated margin mode, only those 2 BTC are at risk of liquidation.
But in cross margin, all the funds in your account serve as collateral for your transactions. If a position loses money, the system may use your entire account balance to prevent this position from being liquidated. However, if things go wrong with multiple transactions, you run the risk of losing your entire balance.
Risk management
Isolated margin allows for more detailed risk management. You can choose how much funds you want to risk for certain trades without affecting the rest of your account. In contrast, Cross Margin combines the risk on all your open positions. This approach can be useful when managing multiple positions that may offset each other, but pooling risk also means higher losses may occur.
Flexibility
If you want to increase the margin in isolated margin trading, you need to manually add more funds to this isolated margin position. Cross margin, on the other hand, requires you to be less involved in the margin management process by automatically using the available balance in your account to prevent liquidation of any positions.
Usage areas
Isolated margin is suitable for investors who prefer to manage risk on a transaction-by-transaction basis, especially those who are very confident in certain transactions and want to keep risks separate. Cross margin is more suitable for traders who work with multiple positions that can hedge against each other or who want to take advantage of the entire balance in their account while managing the margin with less intervention.
Pros and Cons of Isolated Margin
Here are the pros and cons of Isolated Margin:
Pros of Isolated Margin
Controlled risk: You decide how much of your funds you want to allocate and risk for a particular position. Only this amount is at risk and the rest of your money is protected from possible losses in this transaction.
More clarity on profit and loss (PnL): When you know exactly how much funds you have committed to a position, it is easier to calculate profit and loss for that position.
Predictability: In segregation of funds, investors can estimate the maximum loss they may face in the worst-case scenario, which can lead to better risk management.
Cons of Isolated Margin:
Requires close monitoring: Since only a certain portion of funds support a position, you need to monitor the transaction more closely to avoid liquidation.
Limited leverage: If a trade starts to move against you and approaches liquidation, you won't automatically be able to leverage the rest of your account balance to prevent it. You need to manually add more funds to the isolated margin.
Management overhead: Balancing multiple isolated margins for different trades can be complex, especially for beginners or those managing multiple positions.
In summary, while isolated margin offers a controlled environment for managing risks in leveraged trading, it also requires more active management and can sometimes limit profit potential if not used wisely.
Pros and Cons of Isolated Margin
Here are the pros and cons of Cross Margin:
Pros of Cross Margin
Flexibility in margin allocation: Cross margin automatically uses the entire available balance in the account to prevent liquidation of any open positions, providing greater fluidity compared to isolated margin.
Offsetting positions: Gains in one position can help offset losses in another position, which can make cross margin useful for hedging strategies.
Reduced risk of liquidation: When you collect your entire balance in a pool, the risk of early liquidation for a position is reduced as margin requirements can be met by a larger pool of funds.
Easier management of multiple transactions: Since you do not need to adjust the margin of each transaction separately, the process of managing multiple transactions at the same time becomes simpler.
Cons of Cross Margin
Higher risk of total liquidation: If all positions move against you and the losses on these positions exceed the total account balance, there is a risk of losing the entire account balance.
Less control over individual trades: Since margin is shared by all trades, it becomes difficult to allocate a specific risk-return ratio to trades.
Possibility of excessive leverage: The ability to easily leverage the entire balance may lead investors to open larger positions than they would with isolated margin, which may lead to larger losses.
Less clarity of risk level: It is more difficult to calculate the total risk level at first glance, especially when there are multiple open positions with different degrees of profit and loss.
An Example Using Both Isolated Margin and Cross Margin
Integrating isolate and cross strategies together can be a subtle way to maximize return and minimize risk in crypto trading. Let's examine how this works through an example.
Let's say you think the price of ether (ETH) will rise due to upcoming upgrades, but you also want to hedge against potential risks from general market volatility. You suspect bitcoin (BTC) may fall while ether rises.
You might consider allocating a specific portion of your portfolio, say 30%, to open a leveraged long position in ether using isolated margin. This way, you limit potential losses to this 30% in case ether does not perform as you expect. But if ether rises, you could make a significant profit with this part of your portfolio.
With the remaining 70% of the portfolio, you use cross margin by opening a short position in bitcoin and a long position in Z, an altcoin that you believe will perform well regardless of bitcoin's movements.
This way, you use potential gains in one position to offset potential losses in the other position. If the price of Bitcoin falls (as you predicted), you can offset any loss in Z with the profit you make from it, and vice versa.
Once you create this position, you need to constantly monitor both strategies. If Ether declines, you may want to consider reducing the isolated margin position to limit losses. Similarly, if the Z in the cross-margin strategy begins to significantly underperform, you may want to consider adjusting positions.
By integrating both isolated and cross margin, you hedge against risk while also actively seeking to profit from your market picks. But while combining these strategies can help manage risk, it does not guarantee profits or protection from losses.
Last word
While margin trading has the potential to increase the odds of making a profit, it also comes with an equally, if not higher, risk. The choice between isolated margin and cross margin depends on one's trading strategy, risk tolerance, and how actively one wants to manage one's positions.
Understanding the intricacies of both margin types is crucial in crypto trading, which is notoriously volatile. Combining informed decisions with diligent risk management practices can help investors navigate the turbulent waters of the crypto market. As always, it is very important to do thorough research and, if possible, consult experts before starting margin trading.
Additional Reading
What is Margin Trading?
What is Leverage in Crypto Trading?
How to Hedge in Crypto and Seven Hedging Strategies You Should Know
Disclaimer and Risk Warning: This content is provided to you "as is" for general information and educational purposes only, without any representation or warranty of any kind. This content should not be construed as financial, legal or any other professional advice and is not intended to recommend the purchase of any particular service or product. You should seek advice for yourself by consulting appropriate professional counsel. Please note that the opinions expressed in articles contributed by a third party are those of that third party and do not necessarily reflect the views of Binance Academy. For more information, you can read our full disclaimer here. Digital asset prices may fluctuate. The value of your investment may fall as well as rise and you may not get back the amount you invested. You are responsible for your investment decisions and Binance accepts no liability for any losses incurred. It is not investment advice. For more information, see our Terms of Use and Risk Warning sections.
