Fidelity recently updated its S-1 application with the United States Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), seeking approval for its spot Ether exchange-traded fund (ETF), a move that reflects broader industry shifts and regulatory nuances.
The revised application highlights that the underlying Ether tokens in the ETF will not be staked, adhering to the SEC’s requirements for publicly traded securities products.
Shifts in Regulatory Attitudes
The asset management giant submitted an updated S-1 registration form to the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), indicating that the Ether tokens underlying its proposed exchange-traded fund (ETF) will not be staked. This amendment is timely, as there appears to be a change in regulatory attitudes towards spot Ether ETFs in the United States.
Previously, the SEC seemed poised to deny such applications, evidenced by regulatory filings, public statements from SEC Chair Gary Gensler, and ongoing investigations. However, recent developments suggest a potential reversal in this stance. Analysts James Seyffart and Eric Balchunas from Bloomberg have adjusted their forecasts for the approval probabilities of a spot Ether ETF from a mere 25% to an optimistic 75%.
This shift, they suggest, is due to the ETF becoming a contentious political issue, a sentiment echoed across multiple industry sources. Seyffart expressed concern over the political ramifications of the SEC’s changing approach, hinting at significant discussions and possibly a slew of filings in the days to follow. He acknowledged the high stakes involved, especially given the vocal and engaged Ether community that closely monitors such developments.
Pending Decision for VanEck’s Spot Ether ETF
The SEC’s decision-making process is under the spotlight with a pending deadline for VanEck’s spot Ether ETF set for May 23. This application is among the first in a series under consideration, with other major financial entities like ARK 21Shares, Hashdex, Invesco Galaxy, BlackRock, and Fidelity also awaiting outcomes. The SEC has utilized the full extent of its regulatory timeline concerning VanEck’s application, indicating a thorough review process.
Parallel to these developments, the classification of staked Ether continues to be a contentious topic. The SEC has previously indicated that cryptocurrencies that allow staking might meet the criteria of securities under the Howey test.
This perspective was supported by statements made by Gensler during a 2022 Senate Banking Committee hearing, as reported by The Wall Street Journal. The transition of Ethereum to a proof-of-stake (PoS) model adds layers to this debate, potentially influencing the SEC’s regulatory approach.
Legislative Actions and the Broader Regulatory Landscape
Despite a possible softening on the approval of Ether ETFs, the distinction between Ether and staked Ether remains significant. Alex Thorn, head of research at Galaxy Research, speculated that the SEC might differentiate between non-staked ETH and staked ETH or “staking as a service” models, treating the latter as securities. This nuanced view suggests the SEC is attempting to navigate complex regulatory and technical landscapes.
Fidelity’s initial March 27 filing for the ETF proposed staking a portion of the ETH holdings, acknowledging the risks associated with staking, such as potential fund losses through slashing penalties and liquidity issues. It also recognized the tax implications of staking rewards, which would be considered income for the fund, leading to taxable events for investors without direct distributions.
The evolving regulatory framework and Fidelity’s strategic adjustments in its ETF proposal illustrate the intricate balance between innovation, investor protection, and regulatory compliance in the rapidly growing cryptocurrency sector. As the deadline approaches, the industry awaits the SEC’s decisions, which could set significant precedents for the future of cryptocurrency investments and the broader financial landscape.
The post Fidelity Updates Ether ETF S-1 Filing, Excludes ETH Staking appeared first on Coinfomania.
