Price Convergence and Funding Fees in Perpetual Futures Markets

Disclaimer: Digital asset prices can be volatile. Do your own research. See full terms and our risk warnings. Binance Futures products may not be available or may be restricted in your region. This communication is not intended for persons to whom the aforementioned restrictions apply.

Main Takeaways:

• Binance Futures trading involves concepts such as backwardation and funding fees.

• Contango is when futures prices are higher than the spot price, possibly leading to positive funding rates, while backwardation is the opposite scenario.

• High funding fees can pose risks, especially if they lead to liquidation due to margin constraints.

• Traders can employ various strategies and Binance tools to mitigate risks arising from market divergence, such as Price Protection.

Futures and Spot Market: A Primer

Cryptocurrency futures are contractual agreements wherein participants agree to trade an underlying crypto asset at a certain price on a future date. The significance of futures prices in relation to spot prices plays a crucial role in understanding market dynamics.

Price Convergence in Traditional and Crypto Delivery Futures Markets

In both traditional and crypto markets that offer delivery futures, a phenomenon called 'price convergence' is observed as the expiration or delivery date of the futures contract approaches. Price convergence is the process wherein the futures price and the spot price come together, narrowing any difference between them.

Several factors drive this convergence:

• Delivery Mechanism: As the expiration date nears, the futures contract becomes due for physical delivery (or settled as per the contract's terms). Traders holding contracts are obligated to either deliver the underlying asset (if short) or accept the delivery (if long). Hence, as the delivery date approaches, the futures price becomes more in line with the spot price to reflect the reality of the impending transaction.

• Arbitrage Opportunities: Disparities between futures and spot prices create opportunities for arbitrage. For example, if the futures price is higher than the spot price, traders can buy the asset in the spot market and simultaneously sell the futures, thereby locking in a risk-free profit. Such arbitrage activities contribute to driving the two prices closer together.

• Reduced Speculation: As the expiration date approaches, speculators, who might not want to deal with the delivery, start closing their positions, leading to reduced price volatility and further driving convergence.

Backwardation and Contango Explained in Detail

Backwardation:

Backwardation occurs when the futures price of an asset is lower than its current spot price. 

This scenario typically arises due to:

• Supply/Demand Imbalances: A sudden surge in supply or a drop in demand can push futures prices below the spot price.

• Market Sentiment: A prevailing pessimism in the market about the asset's future prospects or value.

• External Factors: Influences such as impending regulatory changes, shifts in macroeconomic conditions, geopolitical events, or other unforeseen market dynamics.

Contango:

Contango is the opposite of backwardation, where the futures price of an asset is higher than its current spot price. The reasons for contango can include:

• Anticipated Future Demand: A projection of increased demand in the future can cause futures prices to rise above spot prices.

• Market Sentiment: General optimism about the future price or potential of an asset, driven by positive news, innovations, or other favorable conditions.

• Carry Costs: In some traditional futures markets, costs associated with storing a physical asset until the futures contract's expiration can contribute to contango. For instance, commodities like oil can have storage costs that get factored into the futures price.

An example of contango could be seen in the early stages of a technological breakthrough where the market anticipates increased demand and adoption in the future, pushing futures prices above current spot prices.

Perpetual Futures vs Traditional Futures

Traditional futures have an expiration date leading to settlement, where prices converge with the spot price. Perpetual contracts, primarily offered by crypto-derivative exchanges, differ in that traders can hold positions indefinitely.

Traditional Futures

A Futures contract is a derivative instrument with its own distinct trading pair, driven by its demand and supply, thereby establishing its own price. In traditional futures markets, such a contract entails an agreement to buy or sell an asset at a predetermined price at a specific future date. These contracts usually undergo a daily settlement process where profits or losses are credited or debited from a trader's account daily, based on the comparison between the closing market price of the day and the previous day's settlement price. This not only ensures adequate margin coverage for potential losses but also offers arbitrage opportunities, keeping the futures contract price in close alignment with the underlying asset's spot market price.

Perpetual Crypto Futures

Conversely, the crypto market operates 24/7. Binance Futures, for instance, introduces perpetual futures contracts, which, true to their name, do not have an expiration date.

Derivatives have their own price determined by distinct demand and supply, yet without a closing market, there is no explicit settlement price, hence no conventional arbitrage opportunity. Given that perpetual futures contracts do not settle traditionally, exchanges the Funding Rate, to ensure that futures prices and index prices periodically converge.

In essence, the funding rate is a fee exchanged at set intervals (typically every 8 hours) between traders holding long and short positions for a trading pair. This fee adjustment modulates the price, ensuring regular convergence between futures prices and index prices.

Hence, unlike the traditional settlement, perpetual futures use a mechanism known as the funding rate to ensure that their prices align with spot prices regularly and mitigate price divergence. 

For a detailed understanding of these differences, you can refer to the article What Is Futures Funding Rate And Why It Matters.

Funding Fees: What are they?

Funding fees are payments to or from traders based on the difference between perpetual contract markets and spot prices. Crypto funding rates, recalculated periodically - with Binance Futures doing so every eight hours, prevent prolonged price divergence between the markets. 

Funding Fee = Funding Rate x Position Notional Value

Where:

• Funding Rate is the periodic rate (could be positive or negative) determined by the difference between futures prices and spot prices.

• Position Notional Value is the size of the open position in the futures contract.

Funding rates consider two components: interest rate and premium, which vary depending on the perpetual contract's price difference with the mark price. Understanding the dynamics of funding rates is vital as they influence traders' profits and losses directly. High funding fees can erode maintenance margins leading to potential liquidations.

Funding fees serve to align the futures price with the spot price. 

• When the market is in contango, long position holders pay fees to short position holders. 

• Conversely, in backwardation, short position holders compensate those in long positions.

Balancing Dynamics: How Funding Fees Regulate Market Positions in Contango and Backwardation

In response to market conditions like contango or backwardation, funding fees act as a self-correcting mechanism. 

• When contango is prevalent, and futures prices are higher than the spot, positive funding rates incentivize traders to take short positions, exerting downward pressure on futures prices to align with spot prices. 

• Conversely, during backwardation, where futures prices are below the spot price, negative funding rates encourage traders to take long positions, pushing the futures prices upward toward the spot. 

This dynamic ensures that perpetual futures markets remain efficient and closely tethered to underlying spot prices, fostering market stability and minimizing prolonged price discrepancies.

The Dynamics of Funding Fee Intervals

Funding fees play a pivotal role in ensuring that futures prices align closely with spot prices. The periodicity and computation of these fees vary from one crypto exchange to another, with the most common intervals being 8 hours, 4 hours, and 1 hour. Each interval comes with its inherent advantages and disadvantages.

Adjusting to Market VolatilityFor example, more frequent funding rate adjustments, such as 1-hour intervals, allow for quick market response during high volatility. High volatility increases the chances of divergence between futures and spot prices. By updating the funding rate more frequently, exchanges attempt to expedite convergence. However, this also implies more frequent trading to avoid paying these fees, resulting in higher turnover and potentially increased trading costs for the users.

Binance's Hybrid Approach

On the other hand, Binance has chosen a hybrid approach. Depending on the specific futures contracts, they utilize both 8-hour and 4-hour intervals. This strategy optimizes the chances of prices converging by offering a balance between responsiveness and stability.

Capping Funding Fees: A Double-Edged Sword

Exchanges also differ in how they cap (or don't cap) funding fees. Some exchanges set a maximum limit on funding fees to protect traders from exorbitant costs during extreme market conditions. You can Binance funding fees cap on the Real-Time Funding Rate page. While this might be beneficial for traders looking for predictability in their expenses, it could sometimes fail to provide the required incentive for the market to align the futures and spot prices. Conversely, exchanges without caps offer a pure market-driven approach, where the fees can go very high, reflecting the true market sentiment and conditions, but this can be burdensome for traders who might not anticipate such high fees.

How to Navigate the Challenges posed by High Funding Fees

High funding fees, especially uncapped ones, can pose a concern to traders if they spike, and potentially lead to liquidation if they consume the maintenance margin.

To tackle the challenges of backwardation and high funding fees:

• Diversify your strategies.

• Stay informed about market conditions.

• Employ risk management techniques such as stop-losses.

• Monitor funding fees and market premiums/discounts continuously.

Tools set by Binance to help Mitigating risks arising from price volatility and funding fees: 

TP/SL orders

These automated orders allow traders to lock in profits or prevent excessive losses when there are sudden price divergences. By setting a TP/SL, traders can navigate volatile markets that could be influenced by significant funding fee changes.

For more information about TP/SL orders, refer to the dedicated FAQ.

Price Protection

To combat the risks arising from extreme market anomalies, Binance offers Price Protection. This tool prevents orders from getting triggered prematurely during drastic divergences between a contract's Last Price and its Mark Price. 

Using Price Protection can ensure traders execute orders closer to the genuine market consensus, minimizing losses from short-lived market anomalies.

For more information about Price Protection, refer to the dedicated FAQ.

Historical and Live Funding Rate Data:

Binance provides a detailed record of past funding rates as well as live funding rate data for all perpetual contracts. Analyzing this data can offer insights into market trends and help traders anticipate future funding rate charges.

Binance Liquidation Calculator:

This tool can be essential when considering the impact of funding fees on position liquidation, especially in highly leveraged positions. By understanding where the liquidation point lies, traders can anticipate how funding fees might push them closer to or further from this point.

Closing Thoughts

Understanding the dynamics of price convergence, backwardation, contango, and the role of funding fees is crucial for traders in the perpetual futures markets, especially on platforms like Binance Futures. 

While these concepts present both opportunities and risks, they are fundamental to the functioning of these markets. Proper comprehension of how futures prices relate to spot prices, and the mechanisms like funding fees that ensure this relation, can enable traders to make informed decisions and employ effective strategies.

Risk Warning:

No Representation 

This content is presented to you on an "as is" basis for general information and educational purposes only, without representation or warranty of any kind. It is not intended or should not be construed as financial or investment advice, nor is it to recommend or intend to recommend the purchase or sale of any specific product(s) or service(s).

Hypothetical Performance Results

Digital asset prices can be volatile. The value of your investment may go down or up, and you may not get back the amount invested. Any results posted herein are intended as examples only to provide you with a reference of what potentially could have made or lost trading with the technical indicators and tools, but are in no way a reflection of what you could have made or lost in the same situation. Therefore, you should not rely on the results as a representation of what your returns or losses would have been utilizing such technical indicators. 

There are numerous other factors related to the market in general or to the implementation of any specific trading program which cannot be fully accounted for in the preparation of hypothetical performance results and all of which can adversely affect actual trading results. Past performance should not be taken as an indication or guarantee of future performance, and no representation or warranty, expressed or implied is made regarding future performance.

Futures trading, in particular, is subject to high market risk and price volatility. You may be called upon at short notice to make additional margin deposits or interest payments. If the required margin deposits or interest payments are not made within the prescribed time, your collateral may be liquidated without your consent. Moreover, you will remain liable for any resulting deficit in your account and interest charged on your account. All of your margin balance may be liquidated in the event of adverse price movement. Past performance is not a reliable predictor of future performance. Before trading, you should make an independent assessment of the appropriateness of the transaction in light of your own objectives and circumstances, including the risks and potential benefits. Consult your own advisers, where appropriate. This information should not be construed as financial or investment advice. To learn more about how to protect yourself, visit our Responsible Trading page.

Responsibilities 

You are solely responsible for your investment decisions, and Binance is not liable for any losses or damages you may incur. The risk warning described herein is not exhaustive, therefore you should carefully consider your investment experience, financial situation, investment objective, risk tolerance level and consult your independent financial adviser as to the suitability of your situation prior making any investment. For more information, see our Terms of Use and Risk Warning.

The products and services referred to herein may be restricted in certain jurisdictions or regions or to certain users in accordance with applicable legal and regulatory requirements. You are solely responsible for informing yourself about and observing any restrictions and/or requirements imposed with respect to the access to and use of any products and services offered by or available through Binance in each country or region from which they are accessed by you or on your behalf. 

Binance reserves the right to change, modify or impose additional restrictions with respect to the access to and use of any products and/or services offered from time to time in its sole discretion at any time without notification.