Recent research by analytics firm Glassnode reveals that Bitcoin miners have minimal impact on BTC price action during market sell-offs.
This finding, highlighted in Glassnode's weekly newsletter "The Week Onchain," challenges long-standing beliefs about the market influence of Bitcoin miners.
Centralized Exchanges and ETFs Dominate Market Influence
Despite facing challenges since the latest block subsidy halving, which reduced the block reward by 50%, Bitcoin miners' influence on market movements is overshadowed by larger investor entities. Glassnode's analysis indicates that centralized exchanges and United States spot #Bitcoin exchange-traded funds (ETFs) exert more significant control over BTC price dynamics.
As of July 2024, centralized exchanges hold over 3 million $BTC , while #ETFs manage 887,000 BTC. In contrast, wallets affiliated with known miners contain approximately 705,000 BTC. This disparity shines a spotlight on the outsized role of exchanges and ETFs in the Bitcoin market.
"Throughout history, large coin holdings have often been custodied by market-agnostic entities, such as the Mt.Gox trustee, tasked with holding coins recovered after the exchange's collapse and bankruptcy," Glassnode explained. "Similarly, significant coin volumes have been seized by government law enforcement and are periodically sold off in tranches."
Glassnode further noted that institutional-grade custodians and ETFs have recently become prominent players. The suite of 11 new U.S. spot ETFs has accumulated a combined 887,000 BTC, making them the second-largest pool of Bitcoin monitored by Glassnode.
Exchange and ETF Bitcoin Balances Versus Miner Holdings
On a weekly basis, Glassnode observed that miner balances fluctuate by about 500 BTC—a stark contrast to the balance changes of exchanges and ETFs, which can vary by approximately 4,000 BTC each week. This discrepancy suggests that the market influence of exchanges and ETFs is four to eight times greater than that of miners.
"Miners have historically been a primary source of sell-side pressure; however, their supply relevance decreases with each halving event," "The Week Onchain" noted.
Recent market dynamics, such as the German government's multi-billion-dollar #BTC distribution, have further shifted the focus away from miners. While substantial, on-chain data suggests that markets had already priced in Germany's distribution in advance.
"The Bitcoin market absorbed a significant 48,000 BTC over the past month as the German Government completed their balance sheet distribution," Glassnode concluded. "This complete exhaustion of the German Government sell-side pressure has provided the market with ample relief, while initial signs of renewed demand have stimulated positive price action."
Optimism for Bitcoin Miners' Future
Despite their reduced market influence, the future may hold promise for Bitcoin miners. As previously reported by Cointelegraph, Bitcoin's hashrate has attempted to reach all-time highs in the past week, and the hash ribbons indicator suggests improving profitability conditions.
The hash ribbons indicator, which measures 60-day and 30-day rolling hashrate, indicates that a miner "capitulation" phase is ongoing. "The faster moving average is growing again and will soon surpass the slower one. This means that the total hash rate, which is correlated with the price, has started to grow again," on-chain data platform Bitcoin is Data shared on X on July 15.
